A Comprehensive Analysis of VPN Comparative Test by AV-TEST 2024

Introduction

In our interconnected digital world, the importance of online privacy and security cannot be overstated. Virtual Private Networks (VPNs) have risen to prominence as essential tools in the quest for digital anonymity and data protection. Recognizing the critical role VPNs play, AV-TEST, an independent and highly regarded testing institute, conducted an extensive performance test on various VPN providers. This blog post aims to provide an in-depth analysis and discerning insights into the VPN Comparative Test by AV-TEST, helping readers understand which VPN services stand out in terms of speed, security, and reliability.

VPN Comparative Testing Approach

AV-TEST embarked on a methodical approach to evaluate the VPNs. The testing protocol involved measuring the download and upload performance of various VPN services in three key geographical regions: the US, Europe, and East Asia. This selection of regions was strategic, encompassing a diverse range of network environments and user bases.

The performance testing tool employed was a sophisticated third-party command-line application from speedtest.net. To ensure the accuracy and consistency of the results, each test was conducted five times with a one-minute interval between each run. This methodology allowed for a comprehensive understanding of each VPN’s capabilities under varying network conditions.

VPN Comparative Testing Performance Results:

Download performance

In the VPN Comparative Test conducted by AV-TEST, the download performance of various VPN providers was evaluated in three different geographical locations: Asia, the EU, and the US. Here are the details of the download performance for each location:

Asia:

• NordVPN outperformed all other VPN products in Asia, with results almost twice as good as the next two products, PrivateVPN and TorGuard.
• PrivateVPN and TorGuard also showed significantly better performance compared to the rest of the products, which achieved only two-digit or one-digit download rates in the region.

EU:

• Private Internet Access had a slight lead over NordVPN in the EU, with both products performing reasonably well.
• PrivateVPN, PureVPN, and TorGuard followed closely behind, performing better than in the Asia location.
• ExpressVPN and ProtonVPN were at the lower end of the list in terms of download performance.

US:

• NordVPN performed substantially better than other VPN products in the US, outperforming the second-placed PrivateVPN by more than a quarter of the download speed.
• PrivateVPN maintained its second-place position in this location, followed by ProtonVPN, TorGuard, and PureVPN.

Overall, NordVPN consistently showed superior download performance across all three geographical locations, while PrivateVPN, TorGuard, and PureVPN also demonstrated relatively good performance in certain regions.

Upload performance

According to the information from multiple sources, the upload performance of VPN providers was tested in three different geographical locations: the US, Europe (EU), and Asia. Here are the details of VPN Comparative Test:

Europe (EU):

• The unsecured upload performance in the EU was the slowest among all tested regions.
• NordVPN showed the highest upload performance, almost doubling the performance of the second-placed PureVPN.
• PureVPN ranked second, followed by Private Internet Access in third place.
• PrivateVPN and TorGuard had a significant drop in performance and came in fourth and fifth place.
• ExpressVPN and ProtonVPN were placed last in terms of upload performance.

US:

• The US had the best upload reference speed among the three locations.
• The performance ranking of VPN providers in the US was almost identical to the download ranking.
• NordVPN was the leader by a significant margin.
• PrivateVPN and TorGuard were almost equal and ranked second and third.
• ExpressVPN, Private Internet Access, and PureVPN had similar performances.
• ProtonVPN had poor performance in Asia but managed to get good average results in the US compared to some competitors.

Asia:

• Asia showed solid performance without an active VPN.
• NordVPN outperformed the second and third products (PrivateVPN and TorGuard) by over 50%.
• Private Internet Access ranked fourth with a small drop in performance.
• ExpressVPN, ProtonVPN, and PureVPN had underwhelming performances.

These details provide insights into the upload performance of VPN providers in different geographical locations.

Overall Network Performance of VPN Comparative Testing

The overall VPN Comparative Test providers in the test were evaluated based on the combined download and upload speeds. NordVPN emerged as the top performer, outperforming all other VPN products by a significant margin. It consistently delivered fast network speeds in both local and overseas connections, sometimes even doubling the performance of its closest competitor.

PrivateVPN and TorGuard secured the second and third positions, respectively, with stable and consistent performance across all tested locations. ExpressVPN, Private Internet Access, and PureVPN followed closely behind, with similar overall performances in terms of speed.

ProtonVPN ranked last in the overall network performance, primarily due to poor performance in Asia. However, it did manage to achieve good average results in the US compared to some of its competitors.

In summary, NordVPN demonstrated exceptional network performance, securing the top spot in the majority of speed tests. PrivateVPN and TorGuard also performed well, consistently delivering solid performance across all regions. The other VPN providers had varying strengths and weaknesses but generally showed similar overall performances.

Key Takeaways and Implications

The comprehensive performance test conducted by AV-TEST offers several crucial insights:

1. NordVPN emerged as the top performer in terms of download and upload performance in all three geographical locations (US, UK, and Japan). It consistently outperformed other VPN products and sometimes even doubled its performance.
2. PrivateVPN and TorGuard secured the second and third positions, respectively, with stable and consistent performance across all locations.
3. The overall network performance, which combines download and upload speeds, indicated that NordVPN had a significant lead of over 60% compared to other VPN products.
4. The performance of VPN products varied across different geographical locations. In the US, the industry average performance was the best, with NordVPN leading the pack. In the EU, Private Internet Access had a slight lead over NordVPN, while in Asia, the industry as a whole performed slightly better than in other locations.
5. The test results showed that the performance of VPN products can be influenced by factors such as the time of day and the workload in each location.

Conclusion

The VPN Comparative Testing by AV-TEST provides invaluable insights into the world of VPNs, particularly for users who prioritize speed and reliability. NordVPN, with its outstanding performance across all metrics, stands out as the go-to choice for those seeking an efficient and reliable VPN service. PrivateVPN and TorGuard also earn their stripes as dependable alternatives. The study underscores the need for users to consider their specific needs and geographical locations when selecting a VPN, as the performance can vary significantly based on these factors.

In a digital era where data security and privacy are more critical than ever, this analysis by AV-TEST serves as a crucial guide for anyone navigating the complex VPN landscape. Whether for personal use or professional requirements, understanding these performance metrics is key to choosing a VPN that aligns with individual needs and expectations.

Follow us for more practical information about VPN. Contact us if you have any further questions!